Name: Old School Pub & Grill
Address: 551 Warwick Turnpike, West Milford, NJ 07421, USA
Telephone: (973) 853-7474
Rating: 4.5

About Us

Nestled in the heart of West Milford, NJ, Old School Pub & Grill combines the nostalgic charm of a traditional pub with the modern flair of a gourmet grill. Our establishment, located at 551 Warwick Turnpike, is more than just a bar or restaurant; it's a local gem where friends and families gather to share memorable meals and moments. Our menu, though simple, features perfectly cooked, high-quality food including some of the best burgers in town. Each dish is crafted with love, attention to detail, and the finest ingredients. The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, thanks to our friendly staff and the sweetest bartenders around, like Kristin, who ensure every visit is a delightful experience. Whether you're stopping by for a late-night snack or a hearty meal, Old School Pub & Grill promises a satisfying culinary journey.

What We Offer

At Old School Pub & Grill, we pride ourselves on offering a range of services designed to enhance your dining experience. From our carefully curated menu of pub classics and grill favorites to our selection of fine liquors and beverages, there's something for everyone to enjoy. Our kitchen excels in cooking up mouth-watering dishes to perfection, whether it's our renowned burgers or our appetizing sides like mozzarella sticks and fries. In addition to our dine-in service, we offer a cozy ambiance perfect for casual outings, family dinners, or celebratory gatherings. Despite our small parking lot, the quality of our food and service makes carpooling worth it.

Why Choose Us

Expertly cooked, high-quality meals in a comfortable setting.

Friendly and attentive service from the best bartenders in town.

A menu that highlights the perfect brioche bun for our burgers.

A local gem with a cozy atmosphere for memorable dining experiences.

Conveniently located with a highly recommended carpooling option.

What Our Customers Say

Don't just take our word for it - hear from our satisfied customers

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

"Stopped in on a Thursday late night for a delicious night cap lol...From the sweetest best bartender on this plant Kristin.. She also fried up some mozzarella sticks and fries... I'm so glad I came here.. It was so worth it! Delicious! She even went above and beyond by recommending, their house I.P.A which was so good.. I will definitely return again! And recommend this place."

— Jimmy

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

"LOCAL GEM. I challenge you to find a better restaurant burger anywhere! These guys put a lot of love and thought into what they do. Brioche bun, but not just any common brioche bun. The perfect one for a juicy hamburger. Plus thick cut, flavorful, bacon. And a thick creamy slice of American Cheese (Note: $2 OFF each hamburger when NY teams are playing. Plus $5 OFF on wings!). The Sweet Potato fries were perfect. Fries and Onion Rings good (nothing special BUT solid and not greasy). The Long Island was one of the best I’ve had. Fun Localized Drink Menu. Service was attentive and patient. Limited Seating so best for groups between 4-6 people max. 1 Pool Table. Patio Dining Available. I must try. Shout out to Bella for taking such great care of us. Update: Went again 03-15-24. Burger not half as good as last time. Place smelled (needs more fresh air). Long Island still good."

— N. H.

⭐⭐⭐⭐

"Excellent quality food and friendly service. Lots of good burger choices. Menu is simple and limited, but everything was cooked to perfection. Parking lot is a bit small, so carpooling is recommended."

— brian creeley

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

"This place is the best! Amanda is an incredible bartender with awesome skills!! 💜 Cozy, warm & fun place you can get some good food and play a competitive game of pool with some of the best! 🎱"

— isabella walczak

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

"My husband and I went for the first time last night & can't say enough good things about this place. It's fun and welcoming, with inexpensive food & drinks, and open LATE (and we're night owls). The music playlist is terrific, and the whole atmosphere just transported us back to the dive bars we'd hang out at in the city in the '90s & '00s (except cleaner). It's 20 minutes from our house, but it's 100% our new local."

— Larissa Symbouras

Frequently Asked Questions

What type of food does Old School Pub & Grill serve?

We specialize in pub classics and grill favorites, with a focus on high-quality, perfectly cooked burgers and sides.

Do I need to make a reservation?

Reservations are not required but recommended for larger groups to ensure a great experience.

Is there parking available at Old School Pub & Grill?

Yes, we have a parking lot available, although it's a bit small. Carpooling is recommended.

Does Old School Pub & Grill offer vegetarian options?

Yes, we offer a selection of vegetarian-friendly dishes. Please ask our staff for recommendations.

Can I order food to go?

Absolutely! You can order online through our website or call us directly at (973) 853-7474 to place your order.

Taste Tradition at Old School Pub & Grill

About Us

What We Offer

Why Choose Us

Gallery

What Our Customers Say

Frequently Asked Questions

Hours of Operation

Get In Touch